It was against Southern Illinois, who was Division 1-AA at the time.
I was there for that and while Howard was a solid college back and a good fullback in the NFL.....they force fed that record to him. Red Grange had 6 TDs versus Michigan, which most agree is still the bar.
SIU started the game off up 21-7, which 7 of those came on a Griffith fumble for a TD. After that, it was the predicted utter destruction.
We ended up winning that game 56-21. It was one of those cool moments to say you saw it live, but at the same time, it was manufactured by forcefeeding him touches against a team that we should have beaten by 50+ points. We were legitimately good during those years.
Love Howard, but your reaction to it is the reason that I'm not a big fan of the record. It's like a MLB pitcher throwing a perfect game against a High School team, then having it go in the record books.
We you start surpassing names like Jim Brown(43 points in a game) and Red Grange.....that game shouldn't be part of those conversations.