Illinois Hoops Recruiting Thread (April-June 2016)

Status
Not open for further replies.
#1,501      
let's laminate it and send it over to the coaching staff as a cheat sheet
 
#1,502      
Answered my own question. I think it is Mayan Kiir from Victory Rock Prep. 6'9"/200 .

What are the current thoughts of this guy? Video I seen (can't find now) seemed pretty good. I can find this one, though: https://youtu.be/eoue-6MnxVU


Seems like this kid is WAY better than Tilmon even though his rankings have him barely in the top 100 on most sites I have seen?

Why are we not talking about him? Only school interest I have seen on his profiles besides us is Louisville. What am I missing?
 
#1,503      
That shouldn't be a factor. Groce has talked about redshirting coming down to 2 things. Is the player good enough to play at least 10 mpg? And is he expected to be a big contributor in the future (aka is it worth an extra scholarship year)?
Class balance shouldn't be a factor?
It's not good for the long-term health of your program (assuming we can get there over the next 2-3 years) if you're set up to need to replace half of your roster after any single graduation.
 
#1,504      
I watched 5 of Charlie Moore's games last summer and here's what I think (for whatever it's worth)

-Against elite AAU competition, he frequently looked like the best player on the floor.
-He's an attacking point guard who looks to score, but he's more than a willing passer. He creates offensive opportunities for his teammates by constantly putting pressure on the defense and forcing defenders out of position.
-Unlimited range as a shooter. He does have a habit of jacking up 28-footers occasionally. Shot selection is sometimes questionable, but it doesn't seem to reflect a BBIQ deficiency - it's more of an overconfidence thing. I think he knows they're not good shots. I don't see it being a problem at the next level.
-Outstanding ball handler
-Quick and athletic
-He is a dog. The kid is tough as nails.

Negatives:
-Potential defensive issues, especially if/when playing off the ball and matching up against physical players with length
-Needs the ball in his hands. I think he's likely a better player than TJL (although admittedly I've seen CM a lot more), but the arrangement would work best if CM was able to shift off the ball a fair amount and let Lucas play as a facilitator, and I don't know how well that will go. Could be fine, but Moore's junior year playing alongside Marcus Lovett raises some doubts. Moore looked like a mid-major shooting specialist at best. His senior year he looked like a top-50 player as the full-time PG.

Long story short: he ended up with a composite ranking of #66 in the country for a reason. I think he's still slightly underrated. He's going to be a stud. Hopefully at Illinois.
 
#1,506      
I'm fine with TJL as our PG next year, not sold on Moore as others. Concerned about his size and how his game translates to next level.
It's justified. Lots of people had those same concerns about the kid from Marian Catholic who must not be named.
 
#1,507      
That Kiir kid looks very good

Also very raw and very thin. But I agree looks to have a lot of potential. Not sure why only us and Louisville have been in to see him and nobody has offered him, but there's probably some reason. Agile 6'9 kids usually have some offers by the time they're a junior/senior.
 
#1,509      
That Kiir kid looks very good

Agreed. Looks like he had about 200 blocks in that video. It I'd like to see more offensive post play but he looks athletic and aggressive.

Looks like he handles the ball extremely well for a big guy. And passes well too. :thumb:

We should make this kid our top priority big right now. Take him and Tilmon. Or if we could only have one I think I would take Kiir. Of course, only after reviewing a few more videos. :cool:
 
#1,515      
It's justified. Lots of people had those same concerns about the kid from Marian Catholic who must not be named.

I was going to post the very same thing, we have said this about many different players over the years and often they have given us fits for four years.
 
#1,516      
Getting Moore would be great. I remember when Groce first took the job he said he liked having two PG on the court at the same time. Maybe he will finally get that opportunity.
 
#1,517      
Kiir looks like the type of big man Illinois needs. I would be very happy getting 2 out of 3 from Tilmon, Kiir, or Theo John. Tilmon is a legitimate big with developing moves. Kiir is the athletic quick leaper who is highly coordianted and will likely top out at 6-10. Theo John is a James Augustine type player who will be a solid 4 year player.

I don't think we need another pick and pop 4 who can't defend the interior or rebound. I do like Finke though, but he is bulking up.

Indiana seemed to have 2 or 3 athletic big men this year and they ate our lunch. In addition they have a super fast PG.
 
#1,518      
All these offers can't be legitimate or commitable. I would think the staff would have a priority list, but why offer if the recruit can't commit. Possibly have given higher priority recruits (Tilmon, Goodwin, Eastern) a timeline to commit. If that doesn't happen have to take another recruit. I believe Deron Williams committed in August or September, pretty late to Illinois. JCL also committed in early fall if I recall. So I guess Groce and staff still have about 4-5 months before panic sets in.
 
#1,519      
Illinois becomes the latest to offer 2017 Dillard forward Raiquan Gray. Cincinnati offered yesterday
https://twitter.com/coreyevans_10/status/725100201053179904

https://twitter.com/Tgray4/status/725096904430878726

I believe we NEED this guy. I believe he oozes talent and potential and he is a physical specimen now. You imagine after our S&C coach molds that for a year? YES PLEASE!!!.
I cannot imagine why he doesnt have higher offers. I really hope we can sow this recruit up in a hurry.
 
#1,520      
Yep, you leave Harvard with a law degree, you're basically sitting pretty good in landing a great gig. But not the same with the NBA. Going to UNC, UK or KU hasn't always been beneficial for a kid's NBA future. Sure some blue-blood McDs end up just fine, but there also some recent examples where stock's have severely dropped...

  • SG Wayne Selden KU - was in the same 2013 class as Wiggins and Embid. Was as high as #15 in Chad Ford's 2015 first mock draft, but now is ranked #68 and may go undrafted.
  • PF Cheick Deillo KU - was projected before this season to go #10 in Ford's first mock draft. But couldn't supplant other KU bigs and is now is slated for the end of the first round, if he stays in.
  • PF Carlton Bragg KU - was initially projected by Ford towards the end of the first round, but would have been projected as 2nd rd/undrafted if he had come out.
  • PF Cliff Alexander KU - don't need to rehash this, but clearly it didn't work out, even if he's now in the league. He went into KU projected top 5 in the 2015 draft to an undrafted free agent. Even before he was pulled by Self, he only averaged 18mpg and 7.1ppg.
  • C Dakari Johnson UK, Harrison Twins, UK - let's lump these guys all together because they were all RSCI top 10, but one went undrafted, while the other two went in the 2nd round. Johnson found himself backing up Julius Randle as opposed to being the man on a different team.
  • PF Alex Polythress UK - RSCI #8 in 2012, had to stay all four years, now ranked #79 on Ford's big board. Overshadowed by myriad of other top ten guys.
  • PG Isiah Briscoe UK - RSCI #11 in 2015, #26 in first mock draft, now #73 on the big board. Overshadowed by Murray and Ulis.
  • C Skal Labissiere UK - RSCI #2 in 2015, #2 in first mock draft. Now, end of first round if he stays in.
  • SG Justin Jackson UNC - RSCI #9 in 2014, was #17 in Ford's first 2015 mock draft. Now is #74 on his big board.
  • SF Theo Pinson UNC - RSCI #15 in 2014, finished his soph year averaging less than 5ppg.
  • PF Isiah Hicks UNC - RSCI #14 in 2013, finished his jr year averaging 18mpg and 9ppg.
Except for Bragg, every one of these kids was a top 20 player, but in several of these cases, they had to battle for playing time with guys equally as talented or more seasoned. Seems like a real cautionary tale for these kids and their camps to think about, as for every Julius Randle and Joel Embid, there could be a Dakari Johnson or a Cheick Deillo.

If I'm a Goodwin or Tillman, I'm sure I'd be coming into the situation feeling I'm good enough to start and star at these places, but I may not know who I'm really competing with until it's too late. Like the bigs coming into KU and UK this season, probably didn't think Deillo and Labissiere respectively could still be there. And then if I'm not one-and-done, I have to consider what other studs may be gunning for my position in the 2018 class.

:thumb: Great post.
 
#1,521      
I believe we NEED this guy. I believe he oozes talent and potential and he is a physical specimen now. You imagine after our S&C coach molds that for a year? YES PLEASE!!!.
I cannot imagine why he doesnt have higher offers. I really hope we can sow this recruit up in a hurry.

His tape isnt really anything impressive. Back up plan at best. Im guessing he is looking better on the circuit now? Maybe they caught him on a good day.
 
#1,522      
All these offers can't be legitimate or commitable. I would think the staff would have a priority list, but why offer if the recruit can't commit. Possibly have given higher priority recruits (Tilmon, Goodwin, Eastern) a timeline to commit. If that doesn't happen have to take another recruit. I believe Deron Williams committed in August or September, pretty late to Illinois. JCL also committed in early fall if I recall. So I guess Groce and staff still have about 4-5 months before panic sets in.

25+ 2017 offers. It's first come first serve, right??
 
Last edited:
#1,523      
If I'm a Goodwin or Tillman, I'm sure I'd be coming into the situation feeling I'm good enough to start and star at these places, but I may not know who I'm really competing with until it's too late. Like the bigs coming into KU and UK this season, probably didn't think Deillo and Labissiere respectively could still be there. And then if I'm not one-and-done, I have to consider what other studs may be gunning for my position in the 2018 class.

These kids don't fear competition generally. Everyone thought Ulis was going to Kentucky to get buried at the end of the bench, for example.

I don't think anyone is making the argument that going to a blue blood school is a guarantee against a dropping draft stock. That's a bit of a straw man.
 
#1,524      
Yep, you leave Harvard with a law degree, you're basically sitting pretty good in landing a great gig. But not the same with the NBA. Going to UNC, UK or KU hasn't always been beneficial for a kid's NBA future. Sure some blue-blood McDs end up just fine, but there also some recent examples where stock's have severely dropped...

  • SG Wayne Selden KU - was in the same 2013 class as Wiggins and Embid. Was as high as #15 in Chad Ford's 2015 first mock draft, but now is ranked #68 and may go undrafted.
  • PF Cheick Deillo KU - was projected before this season to go #10 in Ford's first mock draft. But couldn't supplant other KU bigs and is now is slated for the end of the first round, if he stays in.
  • PF Carlton Bragg KU - was initially projected by Ford towards the end of the first round, but would have been projected as 2nd rd/undrafted if he had come out.
  • PF Cliff Alexander KU - don't need to rehash this, but clearly it didn't work out, even if he's now in the league. He went into KU projected top 5 in the 2015 draft to an undrafted free agent. Even before he was pulled by Self, he only averaged 18mpg and 7.1ppg.
  • C Dakari Johnson UK, Harrison Twins, UK - let's lump these guys all together because they were all RSCI top 10, but one went undrafted, while the other two went in the 2nd round. Johnson found himself backing up Julius Randle as opposed to being the man on a different team.
  • PF Alex Polythress UK - RSCI #8 in 2012, had to stay all four years, now ranked #79 on Ford's big board. Overshadowed by myriad of other top ten guys.
  • PG Isiah Briscoe UK - RSCI #11 in 2015, #26 in first mock draft, now #73 on the big board. Overshadowed by Murray and Ulis.
  • C Skal Labissiere UK - RSCI #2 in 2015, #2 in first mock draft. Now, end of first round if he stays in.
  • SG Justin Jackson UNC - RSCI #9 in 2014, was #17 in Ford's first 2015 mock draft. Now is #74 on his big board.
  • SF Theo Pinson UNC - RSCI #15 in 2014, finished his soph year averaging less than 5ppg.
  • PF Isiah Hicks UNC - RSCI #14 in 2013, finished his jr year averaging 18mpg and 9ppg.
Except for Bragg, every one of these kids was a top 20 player, but in several of these cases, they had to battle for playing time with guys equally as talented or more seasoned. Seems like a real cautionary tale for these kids and their camps to think about, as for every Julius Randle and Joel Embid, there could be a Dakari Johnson or a Cheick Deillo.

If I'm a Goodwin or Tillman, I'm sure I'd be coming into the situation feeling I'm good enough to start and star at these places, but I may not know who I'm really competing with until it's too late. Like the bigs coming into KU and UK this season, probably didn't think Deillo and Labissiere respectively could still be there. And then if I'm not one-and-done, I have to consider what other studs may be gunning for my position in the 2018 class.

Unfortunately as I mentioned in previous post, there is not much evidence to support the assertion that Illinois is the safest and fastest path to the NBA for McD AA players. Our best example, among many failures in the last 25+ years is Brian Cook, and it took Brian 4 years to end up at the end of round 1 in the draft. Not every McD AA will have success in the draft or in the NBA (especially after 1 year), but we can't point to UK and KU as failures, since they have historically had much more success putting McD AA in the NBA, even percentage wise. Actually this is a very strong point for Cal and Self. Not sure how you can call Skal Labissiere, Isaiah Briscoe, Braggs, Cheick Diallo etc failures after 1 year.

http://www.illinoisloyalty.com/Forums/showpost.php?p=1211048&postcount=1071
 
#1,525      
With 25 Offers can't imagine they are first come first serve. Especially with 6 to 7 months before the November Official signing day. I could see T Lewis, Goodwin, Eastern, Tilmon, John, and a couple of other bigs (Kiir) being commitable.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back