I went and saw Tillmon and smith last night I've watched both their matchups this year Tillmon has all the tools but he is not very assertive I've came away from both games a little let down he's not as good as I thought he'd be Smith is very good he's strong he finishes he's made for big ten play he's smart and he sees the floor great he's not quick for a point guard that's the only knock I see I'd like Illini to get him but I think he's getting overhyped. I think it'll be interesting to see who's a better college player between him and Goodwin. The best player I've seen this year is Trent Jr. and his teammate Paul Scruggs wasn't far behind. I'd like to know what everyone else thinks
I concur on the Tilmon deal .... I think he'll be a ton better when you put him with quality guards/players that understand the game, recognize his worth, players that are not selfish & work to provide him quality touches/opportunities...
As far as Smith goes...I don't know how you can say Smith is over hyped or overrated (but everyone is entitled to their opinion & they are like cars....everyone has one just a different kind) as I am giving mine....
Here are some the facts:
#1 ranked Goodwin verses Smith 0-2 Smith had 37 & 35
#2 ranked Tilmon versus Smith 0-2 Smith 26 & 19
Smiths team is 20-1....
Smith's speed for college or any level is fine from my perspective but in case you haven't notice Goodwin is not an Usain Bolt by no means could be slower than Smith but both are Smart player & understand angles because you don't have to have blazing speed to be effective but you do have to have a high basketball IQ
You may not be a "Smith" fan ... he doesn't have any major ranking like Tilmon & Goodwin but let's say this you may get your wish to see Trent Fr. because outside of Illinois smith may end up at Northwestern, Ohio State or Indiana then you get to see not only how quick & overrated Smith is but you & the Illini faithful will get to watch Trent try to guard him....smh