The original owner, Ray Timpone, had a reputation as a notorious cheapskate. One time, I ordered a large pizza to go, and he was working the register. I asked if I could have some napkins.Jolly Rogers was awesome and a bit under the radar. My knucklehead friends and I would always wait until the last minute to make reservations for big weekends (Dads Day, Homecoming, etc.) and they could almost always accommodate large parties... as you suggested... amazing pizza!
“How many do you need?” He asked.
“Oh, about seven or eight,” I replied.
He proceeded to hand me three and mumbled, under his breath, “you don’t need seven or eight napkins for that pizza.”