While Im not saying its time to panic(we're far from it but our last few commits give me a touch of concern), I will say some of the "coping posts" are eerily similar to what we were seeing with Weber when some of us were criticizing him for not being able to capitalize on the recruiting end after the 2004-2005 season or living up to the recruiting standard we had the past few decades. People that were saying "im a bit concerned about the recruiting" were viciously attacked with the common slogan of "ranking dont matter" and Bruce will "coach 'em up"
I also believe that Weber is a perfect example of how important top rated players are. With talent(Selfs roster - highly rated roster) we went to the national championship. Without top talent(full of 3-star sleepers sprinkled with an occasional 4 star) he struggled to make the tournament.
Having said all that. My faith will be fully restored and my concerns will be squashed if we see Fears in an orange and blue jersey.
Eh, personally I think Brad's recruiting has been really solid, and it is really the overall roster turnover along with last year's turmoil and missing out on RayJ that has people in knots over recruiting. Let's just for the second ignore this past year (I'll get to it soon) and take it entirely out of the question. Basically, Brad has recruited the following:
2022: Skyy (#34), Jayden (#51), Ty (#55), Sencire (#96)- 4 4stars, and Mayer, TSJ, and Dain who were also all 4stars out of high school
2021: Podz (#72), RJ (#124), Goode (#143), 2 4stars and 1 3 stars, and Plummer and Omar
2020: Miller (#35), Curbelo (#61), CoHawk (#185), Lieb (NR), 2 4 stars, 1 3 star, and 1NR, and Grandison and Hutcherson
Overall, that's solid recruiting by any standard. In 3 years he picked up 7 top 100 recruits and multiple high value transfers. Now let's look at this past year's recruiting:
2023: Hansberry (#61), DGL (#143), Perrin (NR), Moretti (NR), 1 4star, 2 3star, and 1NR, and Guerrier, Harmon, and Domask, all considered 4star transfers
If we look at 2023 objectively, it's not all that different than 2021 with higher rated transfers. Now let's look at 2024:
2024: Morez (#35), Fears (#43), Jakstys (#110), Jase (#162)
If we were to get Fears, that would on paper be a better recruiting class than 2020, which had the looks of being a very very strong one. So recruiting clearly hasn't gone in the tank. So what's the real issue?
And the answer to that is two things: Results and Retention. Looking back at that recruiting, we have failed to retain (some by choice, some not) the following recruits: Skyy (#34), Miller (#35), Jayden (#51), Curbelo (#61), Podz (#72), and RJ (#124). So of the 7 Top 100 recruits he's signed the past 3 years, he was only able to retain 2 of them. Now combine that with last year's chemistry, leadership, and teamwork issues by bringing in some poor locker room guys, and missing out on a big name transfer PG this season, and we've put a bow on the issue.
Overall, Brad's recruiting has been quite quite good , but his ability to retain those recruits along with his more recent poor vetting of character has been the issue. Getting upset about taking a 3star like Jase is like being upset we ever offered CoHawk, Goode, or DGL. Seems silly to me without getting a chance to see him don the jersey. The real question is if Brad does get Fears, whether he can retain him, or retain Ty, Sencire, Amani, and Morez? Because recent history suggests at least 2 of those 5 are walking out the door this year. And that's something that needs to be fixed, stat.