Illinois Hoops Recruiting Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
#126      

The Galloping Ghost

Washington, DC
Not sure how that percentage was calculated, but doing some quick math based off sports reference the returning minutes gets us to a shade below 59% returning. Not trying to say that’s some massive gap (because it isn’t) but I assume that moves us down from a top 5 minutes returning team.

I agree with your statement overall. Brad feels at least an average at retention. Outside of Podz and Tevian Jones, I don’t think we’ve truly lost someone whose become an even ok college contributor. Maybe Epps and Clark fit that bill but honestly all four of the situations mentioned above were seemingly out of Brads hands. I don’t think retention is a check in the cons column of his tenure here.
I'm not calculating this myself. It's a stat from the Big Ten Network. Peep the video at the 1:13 mark.
 
#127      
As I said in another thread, we are 4th in the conference in returning minutes at 69.9%. The narrative that Brad is bad at player retention is just straight-up wrong. He's better than most coaches at it. And for every Epps and RJ, there's Hawk and TSJ. The world is simply different now. Fans have been slow to realize.
I don't think it's quite so black and white.

On one hand, the TF/DMW teams were pretty stable in terms of returning minutes. As is this year's team.

On the other hand, I think we're in like the bottom quarter of the B1G in terms of transfers out (I did the math at one point but can't find the actual stats. Someone can keep me honest if they have time.) There's also the bit about Coleman being the first BU recruit to (presumably) play out his full eligibility for BU.

You can frame it however you want. I do find myself wishing we could keep some of our players around a little longer. But I also won't fault Brad for sticking to his principles.
 
#129      
I don't think it's quite so black and white.

On one hand, the TF/DMW teams were pretty stable in terms of returning minutes. As is this year's team.

On the other hand, I think we're in like the bottom quarter of the B1G in terms of transfers out (I did the math at one point but can't find the actual stats. Someone can keep me honest if they have time.) There's also the bit about Coleman being the first BU recruit to (presumably) play out his full eligibility for BU.

You can frame it however you want. I do find myself wishing we could keep some of our players around a little longer. But I also won't fault Brad for sticking to his principles.
Kofi played 4 years and left for pro ball, feels unfair not to include him. Ayo played 3 and left for pro ball. Trent and DMFW weren't recruited by Brad, but were retained by him for 5 years. Only two people leaving that have stung are Podz and Ace, one had an incredible year that no one saw coming, and the other has had a very rough career riddled with injuries. I'm not sure who else has transfered out that you could be disappointed about? The portal has been a net positive for us in my opinion.
 
#130      

The Galloping Ghost

Washington, DC
I don't think it's quite so black and white.

On one hand, the TF/DMW teams were pretty stable in terms of returning minutes. As is this year's team.

On the other hand, I think we're in like the bottom quarter of the B1G in terms of transfers out (I did the math at one point but can't find the actual stats. Someone can keep me honest if they have time.) There's also the bit about Coleman being the first BU recruit to (presumably) play out his full eligibility for BU.

You can frame it however you want. I do find myself wishing we could keep some of our players around a little longer. But I also won't fault Brad for sticking to his principles.
If you could have anybody back from last year's team, who would it be? The correct answer is TSJ. He also seemed by far the most likely to leave. Going into last season, nobody thought TSJ would be here for two seasons. After the season, it still seemed incredibly likely that he was gone. Yet, Brad managed to keep him. He did the same thing with Ayo and Kofi for their junior years. Two guys that "played their full eligibility" stat won't catch, but again, players that Brad managed to get extra years out of.

Yeah, you can definitely frame it however you want, I guess. I see Brad managing to keep stars for an extra year. I also see him letting several guys walk that straight-up quit on their team. Then there are a few you would have wanted to stay, but things just didn't quite work. Every single team in the NCAA is dealing with this. If I had to choose, give me the guy who gets the extra year out of his stars when nobody believes he can. I cannot wait to see what Terrence does this year. He has All-American written all over him.
 
#131      
Kofi played 4 years and left for pro ball, feels unfair not to include him. Ayo played 3 and left for pro ball. Trent and DMFW weren't recruited by Brad, but were retained by him for 5 years. Only two people leaving that have stung are Podz and Ace, one had an incredible year that no one saw coming, and the other has had a very rough career riddled with injuries. I'm not sure who else has transfered out that you could be disappointed about? The portal has been a net positive for us in my opinion.
I wish Kofi was here 4 years.

Ace, Griffin, Jones, I'll throw Giorgi in too. All would've been nice pieces, perhaps even THE piece needed to get over that elusive second weekend hump.

Jury is still out on Epps and Skyy. But I think Epps will sting.

I actually don't blame the staff for Podz.

And yeah, word on the street is most/all of those kids had some kind of attitude problem, but 18, 19, 20 year olds do tend to be a bit immature. You'd like to have a staff who can manage personalities and help them grow up.

Look, I've been consistently supportive of BU. If you want to bore yourself, read through my posts. As recently as mid to late March, after we were bounced from the tournament, I still predicted he'd get us to a Final Four. A few years ago I told my 70 something year old grandpa that he was about to see the best stretch of Illinois basketball of his lifetime under BU's leadership. And today is more proof of that with our 4th consecutive pre-season AP rankings. Just saying there is a bit of a pattern of him butting heads irreconciably with young, talented, temperamental players. I think it would behoove him and the program to figure out how to retain them a little better.
 
#132      

Big Jack

Decatur
Kofi played 4 years and left for pro ball, feels unfair not to include him. Ayo played 3 and left for pro ball. Trent and DMFW weren't recruited by Brad, but were retained by him for 5 years. Only two people leaving that have stung are Podz and Ace, one had an incredible year that no one saw coming, and the other has had a very rough career riddled with injuries. I'm not sure who else has transfered out that you could be disappointed about? The portal has been a net positive for us in my opinion.
Actually Kofi was only here 3_years
 
#134      
I wish Kofi was here 4 years.

Ace, Griffin, Jones, I'll throw Giorgi in too. All would've been nice pieces, perhaps even THE piece needed to get over that elusive second weekend hump.

Jury is still out on Epps and Skyy. But I think Epps will sting.

I actually don't blame the staff for Podz.

And yeah, word on the street is most/all of those kids had some kind of attitude problem, but 18, 19, 20 year olds do tend to be a bit immature. You'd like to have a staff who can manage personalities and help them grow up.

Look, I've been consistently supportive of BU. If you want to bore yourself, read through my posts. As recently as mid to late March, after we were bounced from the tournament, I still predicted he'd get us to a Final Four. A few years ago I told my 70 something year old grandpa that he was about to see the best stretch of Illinois basketball of his lifetime under BU's leadership. And today is more proof of that with our 4th consecutive pre-season AP rankings. Just saying there is a bit of a pattern of him butting heads irreconciably with young, talented, temperamental players. I think it would behoove him and the program to figure out how to retain them a little better.
Epps had no future with this team after last season, Tevian wasn't good enough, and Griffin stomped a dude (maybe Brad wanted to keep him?). These guys needed to go. I'm not talking about guys who could possibly be good ball players after they leave, we've only lost 2 guys we really wanted to keep, I'm not letting you count Giorgi either!
 
#136      
Epps had no future with this team after last season, Tevian wasn't good enough, and Griffin stomped a dude (maybe Brad wanted to keep him?). These guys needed to go. I'm not talking about guys who could possibly be good ball players after they leave, we've only lost 2 guys we really wanted to keep, I'm not letting you count Giorgi either!
Ok!

Score it however makes you happiest, my friend.
 
#138      
This is correct, I thought he had 1 year of elgibility left when he departed, but it was probably 2 with the extra covid year.
What’s the consensus? Would he have made more money staying? Did he make the right decision?
 
#141      

The Galloping Ghost

Washington, DC
I agree our player retention could be better. But just for reference i started looking at KU’s roster to see how we match up, and last year KU brought in a 4 man class. Grady Dick is now in the NBA and the remaining 3 all transferred. And Bill S. brought in 2 5th years and a 4th year as transfers. New era for sure.

P.S., I think we match up pretty well!
That's the thing here. For all the complaining about player retention, what program is navigating it flawlessly? I'm genuinely asking. Hall-of-fame level coaches are struggling to keep athletes. Here's a fun stat: over 20% of D1 scholarship basketball players entered the transfer portal this past year. Again, every single team in the country is dealing with this.

Edit: And just gonna throw this list of every single player that transferred, including walk-ons.
 
Last edited:
#142      
That's the thing here. For all the complaining about player retention, what program is navigating it flawlessly? I'm genuinely asking. Hall-of-fame level coaches are struggling to keep athletes. Here's a fun stat: over 20% of D1 scholarship basketball players entered the transfer portal this past year. Again, every single team in the country is dealing with this.

Edit: And just gonna throw this list of every single player that transferred, including walk-ons.
Izzo is doing pretty well, but he hasn't really taken advantage of the portal as much as others either.
 
#143      
Ok!

Score it however makes you happiest, my friend.
illinois basketball dance GIF by Fighting Illini Athletics
 
#147      
Izzo? Pierre Brooks transferred out this year. Julius Marble transferred out the year before. Rocket Watts & Foster Loyer transferred out the year before that. Seems like he's not immune to it either.
Also true, really is hard to find a coach who keeps all of their players, I guess a good question is do they always want to keep all of their players or would they rather have some transfers to make bigger splashes in the portal.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.