If this board had been around in 2005: “YOU CAN’T GET TO THE FINAL FOUR WITH JACK INGRAM ON THE TEAM!!!!!!!!”
I highly doubt that, I remember Jack Ingram being pretty universally loved. Also Jack Ingram got 9 mpg and 15 mpg in his 2 Illini seasons. Humrichous got 26 mpg, and I'm pretty sure over the first half of the season it was around 31 mpg. It was his inadequacies on the court that forced those minutes to come down.
THAT is the problem many have with Humrichous. If you look at per minutes played stats, he was clearly our worst player. If he's on the court, by definition someone else is not. Early in the season when he was taking the minutes of a likely 1st round draft pick, that was insane. When he was taking the minutes of Morez who was an elite rebounder, that was crazy, and contributed to us losing Morez.
If Humrichous was getting 15 mpg off the bench, you wouldn't hear a heck of a lot about him. In fact, you could hear the opposite. I'm not a big DGL fan, but he certainly has his fans here. Similar to the backup QB syndrome, if you played him things would be better, with no real proof that would actually be the case.
That is why many are now saying if he's a role player fine, but if he get's 20+ mpg, if he comes back because we are struggling to land a replacement, that's not going to be good Bob.