The Illinois Coaching Search

Status
Not open for further replies.
#1,378      

Ransom Stoddard

Ordained Dudeist Priest
Bloomington, IL
Honestly, I think he goes too far at KU. How he gets out of some of the things that we have heard about unscathed amazes me.

Heard about <> actually happened.

Iowa fans heard about Deon getting a Blazer, cash, and whatever else those rumors wound up being, and none of that resulted in UIUC getting sanctions. Pizza, of all things, got us sanctions.

But that's not to say that KU hasn't developed a finely tuned shenanigans machine. Larry Brown should get a big chunk of that credit.
 
#1,379      
Dirty not so secret: Illinois has crossed that line and come back several times in the past couple of decades. If you think that the 80's happened solely b/c of an established Lou Henson and a Jimmy Collins then you're kidding yourself. If you think Bill Self had to go to KU to become Bill $elf then you're kidding yourself.

Also, John Groce brought a knife to several gunfights, not a wet noodle. He also won his share of knife fights.
 
#1,381      
I liked the Scott Drew idea too but I hear he might be shady? Not to sure what to believe. Also hear he's not liked. Any thoughts?

There's been some whispers about Drew and recruiting, but you have to wonder how much of that is guilt by association due to the scum pond that is Baylor athletics.

Really, he's about the only high-profile individual associated with that school to have any shred of good reputation left to him, and you can certainly see why he'd want to get away from that taint.

On the other hand, any AD would have to be concerned that the Baylor taint would travel with him. One news report of the kind that has been eminating from Waco on an almost weekly basis for about three years now would be enough to bring your new basketball hire crashing down on you.

I could see Drew as coach, but Whitman would have to engage in some "extreme vetting" before making that hire.
 
#1,384      
So read the thread, looks like Buzz Williams, Scott Drew, and Archie Miller would be the home run hires. They would be the ceiling, to the thread, and Martin and Keats are the floor.

Well really it depends on your opinion who the home run hire would be. I wouldn't call Drew or Williams home run hires with their questionable ethics/character issues.
 
#1,386      
I am not the one placing Whitman on a high pedestal, but alot of his lore, not just board talk, was his ability to get a good nfl coach to come and take over a real down football program.

He misses there, and who knows what happens, do we just keep the coach we had?

You're not wrong. It was a bold and exceptional move that was very much "right place, right time". Plenty of casual fans will set that as a standard, unfortunately.
 
#1,388      
So hypothetically, what would a knife look like in the recruiting world compared to a gun?

giphy.gif
 
#1,389      
So hypothetically, what would a knife look like in the recruiting world compared to a gun?

Depends on the kid. A little bit of money here or there, a job for whoever, some funds flowing back to somebody's AAU program for "scouting", whatever.

The struggle for Illinois is for places like Kentucky and Kansas, the head coaches don't even need to know about this stuff. It just gets done. We have allies out there, but not miracle workers like the blue bloods have.

And again, this isn't every kid. Nor are all the ways you can benefit a player and their family necessarily against the rules.
 
#1,390      
When my son inevitably is a 5-star PG recruit, and some boosters are offering $150k for him to go to Indiana, I'm going to teach him how to take that offer to Illinois, ask them for more, then go to the highest bidder out of schools that he would seriously be excited about (and had coaches that I trusted to take good care of my kid).

That's exactly the same process I followed the last time I was on the job market. Learning how to negotiate and leverage an offer is a valuable life skill.

Now, if I got wind that someone wanted to take him to a strip club on his campus visit...well, that's a different story.

I haven't read everyone's comments yet, but I hope I am not the only one who sees a problem with this. The problem isn't the lesson in learning to negotiate and use leverage, but the lesson of cheating when it is to your advantage.

I have a problem with a parent who tells their child "It is against the rules, but hey, look at how it benefits you! Go for it!"





waiting for the ..."but everyone is doing it already." comment.
 
#1,391      
Its only relevant to the bball search because he tried the exact same thing. It's not a casual fan's standard, it's his.

As has been discussed, he didn't flippantly throw out the 4.5 and 2.5 million dollar figures during the press conference. I believe he has two categories of coaches that he is targeting. Monty Williams was the first target, yes, but it is definitely not Monty or bust. He has a plan, and it will not be dragged out.
 
#1,396      
Cuonzo Martin will take this job if offered, and he is a higher caliber coach than Groce.

So, yes.

:thumb:

I don't present this as evidence he is the guy for the job, or even that it is a valid way to judge a coach. It's just numbers.

Martin's record when expunging his first season at each school (his worst at each stop):

Missouri State: 50-21 (23-13)
Tennessee: 44-26 (22-14)
California: 44-23 (22-14)

Total: 138-70 (67-41)

That's not bad. It's not Bill Self, but it's Tom Crean. Maybe we need a Tom Crean before we can get another Bill Self. He hasn't had a real chance to build his program his way over an extended period of time. He's only had short bursts, and after a year of adjustment he's performed pretty well at all three stops. Certainly much better than John Groce has ever performed.

This doesn't excuse obvious coaching deficiencies others have noticed. I am not familiar enough with him to offer an opinion on that. So, no, I'm not making a case for Cuonzo as the next coach. I am, however, making a case that if UI indeed is forced to settle on him, it's not nearly as bad (at face value) as some are suggesting. Given his reputation as a recruiter, with ties to both the STL and Indy areas, as well as mining Chicago for Charlie Moore, and his supposed high regard and desire for the job, he could be a very good consolation prize. I am okay with a guy who might not get UI to the top level, but merely gets the program back to a respectable level. It may be our most realistic hope at this point. The program has lost its luster. Think about what Crean has done at IU and ask yourself if you would be okay with that given how the last 10 years have gone.

All this said, go get Marshall or Miller or Bennett or Buzz. If Cuonzo is seen as a consolation, well, that's not too bad.
 
#1,397      
:thumb:

I don't present this as evidence he is the guy for the job, or even that it is a valid way to judge a coach. It's just numbers.

Martin's record when expunging his first season at each school (his worst at each stop):

Missouri State: 50-21 (23-13)
Tennessee: 44-26 (22-14)
California: 44-23 (22-14)

Total: 138-70 (67-41)

That's not bad. It's not Bill Self, but it's Tom Crean. Maybe we need a Tom Crean before we can get another Bill Self. He hasn't had a real chance to build his program his way over an extended period of time. He's only had short bursts, and after a year of adjustment he's performed pretty well at all three stops. Certainly much better than John Groce has ever performed.

This doesn't excuse obvious coaching deficiencies others have noticed. I am not familiar enough with him to offer an opinion on that. So, no, I'm not making a case for Cuonzo as the next coach. I am, however, making a case that if UI indeed is forced to settle on him, it's not nearly as bad (at face value) as some are suggesting. Given his reputation as a recruiter, with ties to both the STL and Indy areas, as well as mining Chicago for Charlie Moore, and his supposed high regard and desire for the job, he could be a very good consolation prize. I am okay with a guy who might not get UI to the top level, but merely gets the program back to a respectable level. It may be our most realistic hope at this point. The program has lost its luster. Think about what Crean has done at IU and ask yourself if you would be okay with that given how the last 10 years have gone.

All this said, go get Marshall or Miller or Bennett or Buzz. If Cuonzo is seen as a consolation, well, that's not too bad.


There is little doubt that Martin would kill it on the recruiting front at Illinois.
 
#1,400      
There is little doubt that Martin would kill it on the recruiting front at Illinois.

I'd be OK with Martin. Not my first choice (Archie Miller) but I'd be OK with any of Archie, Keatts, Mack, Martin, or Capel. If Cuonzo is successful in recruiting, he will do very well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.