DC Bobby Hauck out at Illinois

Status
Not open for further replies.
#426      
Unpopular opinion. I would like to see Mike Locksley come back as our DC or Pitts DC. Maybe Berry Lunny can bring Jess Loepp from UTSA
 
Last edited:
#429      
He has talent there and they perform at a high level.
He had a couple of solid players here and the results showed. It wasn't always a picture of beauty, but it was enough to win.

I don't know how this falls 100% on the DC. The talent isn't there whatsoever. This defensive line and LB corp is MAC level. We'll see what the next sacrificial lamb brings.
indiana proved a winning team can be built without blue-chip players......bb is a great guy but not convinced great guys win football championships....winning starts with the head on down....
 
#432      
The "soft landing" theory for Aaron Henry being voiced here by many only holds water if Bret Bielema was caught completely off guard by his exit and was intent on keeping him for another year as DC.

To be clear: Bielema almost certainly did wait for Henry to find a soft landing so he wouldn't have to outright fire a former player and long-time protégé. But that managed exit had nothing to do with the search for a new DC or how Illinois ultimately landed on Bobby Hauck.

An experienced head coach doesn't just sit on his hands when a change is needed; he quietly vets replacements behind the scenes long before any public moves happen.

The far more plausible scenario is that Bielema did have a primary target lined up... such as Chris Partridge... only for that deal to fall through at the last minute.

When your Plan A dissolves in February after the standard candidate pool has already been picked clean, you're forced into an emergency pivot. That is precisely how Illinois ended up with an unexpected stylistic shift like Hauck.

Bielema wasn't waiting around passively... he was left scrambling when his top replacement option collapsed at the eleventh hour.

All that may be true, but at the same time, it's also likely true that waiting until February to make the move significantly limited Bielema's options should his Plan A have failed like it did. While Bielema probably wasn't caught off-guard, his seeming loyalty to A-Hen likely ended up being detrimental to the program
 
#434      
indiana proved a winning team can be built without blue-chip players......bb is a great guy but not convinced great guys win football championships....winning starts with the head on down....
They had 8 guys drafted last year, including 2 first rounders, a 2nd, a 3rd, a 4th, a 5th , a 6th and a 7th. They had the #1 pick.in the NFL draft last year.
 
#436      
75% to Hauck, 25% to Henry
So, the guy who recruited them, Bielema, doesn't have any accountability? Not being able to land a serviceable defensive lineman or LB? It's either he's not selling the program or the money isn't there. Have to pick a lane with the reasoning.

If what you're saying is true, I'm expecting a phenomenal outing this weekend on the defensive side because we have the players to accomplish this. They're running the same scheme, so better leadership should fix this? I hope you're right.
 
#437      
So, the guy who recruited them, Bielema, doesn't have any accountability? Not being able to land a serviceable defensive lineman or LB? It's either he's not selling the program or the money isn't there. Have to pick a lane with the reasoning.

If what you're saying is true, I'm expecting a phenomenal outing this weekend on the defensive side because we have the players to accomplish this. They're running the same scheme, so better leadership should fix this? I hope you're right.

I’m not sure how people can’t realize how bad the talent on defense is.
 
#438      
According to the Athletic, Northwestern spends around the same on its roster as us, and likely a little more. This narrative that Northwestern is tough to win at never made a ton of sense (it's s very wealthy institution with tons of wealthy alumni) and it makes less sense now than ever. Crazy how this board treats any Northwestern coach that can tie his shoes and spell his own name like some kind of savant.

None of that gives him experience at a P4 or even G6 prior to Northwestern.
 
#439      
I’m not sure how people can’t realize how bad the talent on defense is.
I haven't a clue. It's painfully obvious, but I think it's a form of self soothing. They want to find someone to blame versus addressing the problem, which is significant. They are hoping that one decision fixes the problem and don't want to accept the fact that that entire side of the ball needs an upgrade and that can't be fixed this year.

There is no way that a reasonable person can't see that the guys we throw out there are slower, less athletic and can't physically match up with the opponent. These other teams a just bigger, taller, faster and have better athletes.....on defense.

We spent our money on the offense. If the reverse was true, these same people would want Lunney fired.

This is not an easy fix when we have no financial answers. That's the crux of the issue.
 
#441      
I haven't a clue. It's painfully obvious, but I think it's a form of self soothing. They want to find someone to blame versus addressing the problem, which is significant. They are hoping that one decision fixes the problem and don't want to accept the fact that that entire side of the ball needs an upgrade and that can't be fixed this year.

There is no way that a reasonable person can't see that the guys we throw out there are slower, less athletic and can't physically match up with the opponent. These other teams a just bigger, taller, faster and have better athletes.....on defense.

We spent our money on the offense. If the reverse was true, these same people would want Lunney fired.

This is not an easy fix when we have no financial answers. That's the crux of the issue.

I do think we had issues with Hauck but I don’t think any DC would look good with the talent we have. The next portal cycle has to be much more balanced. The ROI of the portal and juco class has been very bad. We spent a lot on several prep recruits last year so hopefully they can make an impact soon. We had 4 guards go down this year and TJ Taylor still can’t get on the field. That’s not encouraging
 
#442      
I haven't a clue. It's painfully obvious, but I think it's a form of self soothing. They want to find someone to blame versus addressing the problem, which is significant. They are hoping that one decision fixes the problem and don't want to accept the fact that that entire side of the ball needs an upgrade and that can't be fixed this year.

There is no way that a reasonable person can't see that the guys we throw out there are slower, less athletic and can't physically match up with the opponent. These other teams a just bigger, taller, faster and have better athletes.....on defense.

We spent our money on the offense. If the reverse was true, these same people would want Lunney fired.

This is not an easy fix when we have no financial answers. That's the crux of the issue.
I don't think that anyone is saying that "one decision fixes the problem" at all. There are multiple problems, but the one problem you can fix is the disaster DC that can't even get the correct number of players on the field consistently.

Would you rather that nothing was done and keep Bobby ineptly managing our D? He didn't have the chops or commitment to do the job, not even close.

Kudos to Bobby, he got a solid payday and his kid a shot at a job he never would have had any other way. But that came at a cost to our program.
 
#443      
I don't think that anyone is saying that "one decision fixes the problem" at all. There are multiple problems, but the one problem you can fix is the disaster DC that can't even get the correct number of players on the field consistently.

Would you rather that nothing was done and keep Bobby ineptly managing our D? He didn't have the chops or commitment to do the job, not even close.

Kudos to Bobby, he got a solid payday and his kid a shot at a job he never would have had any other way. But that came at a cost to our program.
If he walked in and shut down his career because he felt overmatched schematically and he felt the defense regressed because of his coaching, then you have to cut bait. No doubt. You can't have a guy who's not 100% in. Is that what happened?

Or did Brett tear him up and strongly "hint" that it wasn't going to work out? Not sure how you can come to that conclusion after four games, but whatever. That's fine. The issue here is that this is on the heels of Henry getting run out and people thinking that was going to help the results. What makes us think that a third DC in four games changes anything?

We had a couple of NFL caliber players on D last year, most notably Jacas and Bailey. Having just one defensive lineman that was worth a salt made a big difference because he was doubled. As a DC, you can work with that to some extent. This years roster has nobody remotely close to having that type of physical impact.
 
#444      
Shut down his career? The guy was retired! He shut down his own career 🤦‍♂️
If he walked in and shut down his career because he felt overmatched schematically and he felt the defense regressed because of his coaching, then you have to cut bait. No doubt. You can't have a guy who's not 100% in. Is that what happened?

Or did Brett tear him up and strongly "hint" that it wasn't going to work out? Not sure how you can come to that conclusion after four games, but whatever. That's fine. The issue here is that this is on the heels of Henry getting run out and people thinking that was going to help the results. What makes us think that a third DC in four games changes anything?

We had a couple of NFL caliber players on D last year, most notably Jacas and Bailey. Having just one defensive lineman that was worth a salt made a big difference because he was doubled. As a DC, you can work with that to some extent. This years roster has nobody remotely close to having that type of physical impact.
u
 
#446      
I’m not sure how people can’t realize how bad the talent on defense is.
That perspective was deemed unwelcome here as the roster was being assembled.

We had a couple of NFL caliber players on D last year, most notably Jacas and Bailey.
That's true, but it hard to overstate how central to our prior defensive strategy the constant deep rotation of big bodies was. Both in terms of performance of those guys, having different packages for situations, and managing the tempo of games.

Individual stars made big impacts, but the defense was depth-based up front at the basic theoretical level.

I think that played a big role in the decision to change philosophies. It's not that we couldn't find another Gabe Jacas in an ideal world, it's that we could never afford Gentle Hunt's and Jeremiah Warren's as depth guys anymore.
 
#448      
That perspective was deemed unwelcome here as the roster was being assembled.


That's true, but it hard to overstate how central to our prior defensive strategy the constant deep rotation of big bodies was. Both in terms of performance of those guys, having different packages for situations, and managing the tempo of games.

Individual stars made big impacts, but the defense was depth-based up front at the basic theoretical level.

I think that played a big role in the decision to change philosophies. It's not that we couldn't find another Gabe Jacas in an ideal world, it's that we could never afford Gentle Hunt's and Jeremiah Warren's as depth guys anymore.

Jeremiah Warren has only played like 30 snaps this year for Pitt so I’m not sure now much he cost. You are right though we will never have the defensive line depth we had last year.
 
#450      
What happened?! I mean all Hauck would say is that he fell in love with coaching again, etc. I know the defense has been poor but honestly we didn’t get rolled like we did last year against Indiana. This is strange for Bret. Must’ve been some verbal disrespect somewhere between Hauck and Bret and or the players or Josh... If someone knows please spill it!
Agree. The defense was better than expected against OSU. I don’t understand why Hauck was not given the season to play it out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back