Coaching Carousel

Status
Not open for further replies.
#55      

Mr. Tibbs

southeast DuPage
Im not sure hes allowed on the sidelines. I know (99%) hes not allowed on the field at practices
maybe Im mistaken
 
#57      

Mr. Tibbs

southeast DuPage
I would say its " more often the players" , than the scheme

but saying that , I would add that you cant rely on rankings out of high school for much. they are often way over skewed in the wrong direction.
See Witherspoon, Devon

so many 4* & 5* players are over rated, and 0* or 1* players simply never were properly rated
but Bama, Ga, O$U and scUM have proven you can go pretty far with a roster full of highly ranked players
 
#58      
Oh honey. We are talking STUPID money here.
There has to be SOME limit, right?? Like, Texas A&M has even more money than Alabama, but they aren't getting Saban. In other words, Alabama would come up with enough cash to get him to stay even if they are marginally below A&M's offer in terms of pure dollars and cents. I would think PSU's prestige is high enough that they could fend off advances from A&M, but then again maybe Franklin is sick of being in the shadow of Michigan and OSU coaching for a fan base that expects to be competing with both.
 
#62      

Another program who has lofty expectations. MSU had a big drop off considering they returned their starting qb
 
#63      

Another program who has lofty expectations. MSU had a big drop off considering they returned their starting qb

Screenshot 2023-11-13 at 10.21.20 PM.png
 
#64      
I don't see Leipold leaving his KU spot until he retires in a few years. They're going to build a statue of him outside their new stadium if he keeps sending them to bowl games in a OU/Texas-free B12.

Whoever A&M picks is going to have to deal with the insanely high expectations that come from that fanbase. Playing in the SEC is a career killer for head coaches unless everything lines up perfectly for them to be successful.
Hear me out. What if TAMU offered him generational wealth?
 
#68      

altgeld88

Arlington, Virginia
What kind of idiots do they have running the show at A&M if they think James Franklin is going to solve their offensive issues?
His decision to go for two (they failed the conversion, natch) at the end of the second quarter v. Michigan last Saturday when they'd finally scored a TD to pull within 14-9 was the single dumbest head coaching decision I've ever seen in 50 years of watching college football.
 
Last edited:
#69      

MustangWally

Mayfield
His decision to go for two (they failed the conversion, natch) at the end of the second quarter v. Michigan last Saturday when they'd finally scored a TD to pull within 14-9 was the single dumbest head coaching decision I've ever seen in 50 years of watching college football.
Time for nominations for even dumber head coach in-game coaching decisions. Surely Zook will appear somewhere on the list.
 
#70      
Ridiculous waste of cash. There’s something wrong with that institution.

"has a lesson to learn" is an understatement. I would make a terrible AD. I would insist on high salaries over these high buy-outs. Especially in this era where program money needs to be available for NIL.
 
#71      

Mr. Tibbs

southeast DuPage
aTm and Mich St both set terrible precedents with the crazy high salaries they were paying to their coaches.
How do you attract anyone really good, to satisfy the fan base, and not pay them just as much ?

I still think Mullen ends up back at Miss St and Harsin ends up back at Boise
 
#72      

altgeld88

Arlington, Virginia
Time for nominations for even dumber head coach in-game coaching decisions. Surely Zook will appear somewhere on the list.
He occupies a stand-alone category, as he was profoundly differently-abled. Guys like John L. Smith keep him company.

JL Smith's complete meltdown on-camera concerning an end-of-half completely boneheaded Spartan coaching error (10 men on field and two OSU linemen with an unimpeded path to block a FG) while being interviewed running off the field at halftime at OSU is among the more amusing college football moments I can recall.

 
Last edited:
#73      

IlliniSaluki

IL metro east burbs of St. Louis
aTm and Mich St both set terrible precedents with the crazy high salaries they were paying to their coaches.
How do you attract anyone really good, to satisfy the fan base, and not pay them just as much ?

I still think Mullen ends up back at Miss St and Harsin ends up back at Boise
The only way I see it is they can keep paying the stupid amounts or hire unproven up and coming lower tier coaches for a few hiring cycles. If I was an established good/great coach currently no way would I go to either school for anything less than the precedent those schools had set for their now fired coaches.
 
#74      
I would say its " more often the players" , than the scheme

but saying that , I would add that you cant rely on rankings out of high school for much. they are often way over skewed in the wrong direction.
See Witherspoon, Devon

so many 4* & 5* players are over rated, and 0* or 1* players simply never were properly rated
but Bama, Ga, O$U and scUM have proven you can go pretty far with a roster full of highly ranked players
This might be true, but I thought this season has been a textbook example of coaches having to adjust their gameplans to stick within what the players can actually do. The failures bringing choruses to fire Lunney on this board, were cleaned up with mostly the same players. As coach B puts it, "We have to ask the right questions...we can only ask of our players what we know they can do." That might still be the same 'scheme' but the coaches made huge adjustments to fix the OL, for example. Did anyone in the top six change? Positions, yes, but I thought same guys.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.