Illini Basketball

Status
Not open for further replies.
#251      
This is a team that, despite having one of the better big men in the country, and a number of good three-point shooters, never figured out how to effectively pass out of a double team or to consistently use guard penetration to get the ball to Kofi or to dish out for open threes. The times that the Illini did that it almost seemed accidental.

Another issue was the lack of a true point guard quarterbacking the offense---how often did we have to watch Coleman Hawkins bringing the ball upcourt?

The Illini also do a poor job of maintaining a flow with the ball: get it, and do something---either drive, pass or shoot. Instead, they stand around and dribble, waiting to try a lob into the post or taking a bad shot as the shot clock winds down.

To me this all boils down to either coaching, or the players' inability to execute a game plan. I can't say Underwood's a poor game coach, but if he's not he has players who aren't able to put his coaching into action.
I'd say a combination of both. Would like to see some different looks and a lot more movement on offense. But we had Damonte who just wasn't an offensive player and Trent and Plummer are both pretty small. I think with a starting lineup of something closer to Curbelo (more crafty), Goode (maybe SKyy), Melendez, Hawkins, and Kofi we would move a lot more rather than stand on the perimeter. At least I would hope we'll have a lot more movement. Again, this will be the first year with all Underwood recruits so hopefully he switches some things up offensively.
 
#252      
I dont think so. Without looking I think Gills year had at least 5 and she me others maybe more. The B10 was very tough back then
There will likely be at least 5 this B1G 1st round picks this year.

Obviously: Ivey, Murray, Davis (top 10)

Very likely: Liddell, Branham (top 20)

Would not be a surprise: Christie, T.Williams (#28 & 30 respectively in latest ESPN Mock)

If workouts go great: Houstan, Edey (both projected in top 40 in ESPN's updated Mock)
 
#253      

BBIQ

Texas
Thanks for recap - I had only heard the Mully show this morning and was going off a poster on yesterday's show.

I will say No. 8 is ridiculous. I mean it's a product of the NCAA Tournament of being the be all and end all to so many people, but winning the Big Ten tournament and Big Ten regular season in back-to-back years and all the great Big Ten wins it took to do that (especially on the road and especially against rivals like Iowa, Michigan, Wisconsin, MSU and Indiana who have been killing us for about 10 straight years), that is not "nothing to show for it." The last three years really with Ayo and Kofi, I can't imagine there's anyone here who thinks we have "nothing to show" for all the great play those two and others have displayed.

Just got to find a way to combine the regular season Big Ten success with tournament success, which I'm sure is everyone inside the program's sole focus right now. Whether it's raising talent level, changing schemes...I trust they are going to get it right.
I agree, it is possible he meant nothing to show for it in the tourney but he didn't say it that way.
 
#254      
There will likely be at least 5 this B1G 1st round picks this year.

Obviously: Ivey, Murray, Davis (top 10)

Very likely: Liddell, Branham (top 20)

Would not be a surprise: Christie, T.Williams (#28 & 30 respectively in latest ESPN Mock)

If workouts go great: Houstan, Edey (both projected in top 40 in ESPN's updated Mock)
One of the most stacked B1G classes I've seen in a while, it's a shame the tourney didn't fall our way again. Last time the B1G had 3+ lottery picks was 2013.
 
#256      
There will likely be at least 5 this B1G 1st round picks this year.

Obviously: Ivey, Murray, Davis (top 10)

Very likely: Liddell, Branham (top 20)

Would not be a surprise: Christie, T.Williams (#28 & 30 respectively in latest ESPN Mock)

If workouts go great: Houstan, Edey (both projected in top 40 in ESPN's updated Mock)
I just looked and there were 5 in 89 and 90 but the first round stopped at 27 so the percentage would have been a bit higher then
 
#258      
Can we maybe just once not set sky high expectations for a kid based on 40 minutes of his freshman season?
To be fair this isn't based on 40 minutes of stats - it's PER 40 minutes. He played closer to 200 minutes this season and an increasing amount of minutes as the season wore on. Is it a small sample size? Sure. Was he scouted by opposing teams? Probably not. But given that he played in 22 games I don't think it's ridiculous to extrapolate his stats for comparison
 
#259      

altgeld88

Arlington, Virginia
To be fair this isn't based on 40 minutes of stats - it's PER 40 minutes. He played closer to 200 minutes this season and an increasing amount of minutes as the season wore on. Is it a small sample size? Sure. Was he scouted by opposing teams? Probably not. But given that he played in 22 games I don't think it's ridiculous to extrapolate his stats for comparison
Loved RJ's assertiveness late in the season. I recall when he entered the game v. Purdue on MLK Day he looked a little lost. By the Houston game he looked completely comfortable, and adept at putting the ball on the floor and driving. Am really excited about what we'll see from him next season.
 
#260      
To be fair this isn't based on 40 minutes of stats - it's PER 40 minutes. He played closer to 200 minutes this season and an increasing amount of minutes as the season wore on. Is it a small sample size? Sure. Was he scouted by opposing teams? Probably not. But given that he played in 22 games I don't think it's ridiculous to extrapolate his stats for comparison
Jaden Ivey had a MASSIVE jump his sophomore season. Expecting anyone to replicate that is not fair.

Comparing to ayos freshman year doesn’t seem fair either given the consistency/volume tied to his freshman year compared to RJs.

I’m just saying, let’s not go around suggesting RJ is going to be a 2 and done 1st rounder because his stats matched Iveys
 
#261      
I dont think so. Without looking I think Gills year had at least 5 and she me others maybe more. The B10 was very tough back then
To be fair, 5 1st round picks in 1990. Some mocks this year show 6 big ten players. So my statement is still accurate that we MIGHT see more than that year. I have not checked every year, but big ten has not produced this many 1st picks in a very long time.
 
#262      
To be fair this isn't based on 40 minutes of stats - it's PER 40 minutes. He played closer to 200 minutes this season and an increasing amount of minutes as the season wore on. Is it a small sample size? Sure. Was he scouted by opposing teams? Probably not. But given that he played in 22 games I don't think it's ridiculous to extrapolate his stats for comparison
Highly doubt he averages 17/8/3 but he’s absolutely shown the ability to play at a very high level. Obviously like you alluded to, helps when you’re third or forth off the benches rather than a focal point but I have no doubts he can be a star.
 
#263      
Jaden Ivey had a MASSIVE jump his sophomore season. Expecting anyone to replicate that is not fair.

Comparing to ayos freshman year doesn’t seem fair either given the consistency/volume tied to his freshman year compared to RJs.

I’m just saying, let’s not go around suggesting RJ is going to be a 2 and done 1st rounder because his stats matched Iveys
Agreed. I think the kid is going to be a stud, but Ayo and Ivey both played starter's minutes their freshman year. (Johnny davis too) There is no substitute for in-game action. The speed, the nerves, the emotion, the officiating, the in game adjustments... You can't simulate those things. You have to experience them to get comfortable. That comfort allows players to play freely and confidently.

Is is possible? Sure! Likely? I don't think so...
 
#264      
Seems like in most respects these days negativity drives talk shows. Draws ears & eyeballs. It's all about the clicks, etc. I quit listening to most of them years ago. If someone has a rational, well thought out argument I'll listen, but that is rare.
Unless they are telling me they have been watching the illinois basketball games in the regular season, I'd rather defer to the average fan on this board that watches all the game in terms of meaningful input or thought.
 
#265      
Agreed. I think the kid is going to be a stud, but Ayo and Ivey both played starter's minutes their freshman year. (Johnny davis too) There is no substitute for in-game action. The speed, the nerves, the emotion, the officiating, the in game adjustments... You can't simulate those things. You have to experience them to get comfortable. That comfort allows players to play freely and confidently.

Is is possible? Sure! Likely? I don't think so...
It’s also very different to compare 200 minutes to starters minutes for an entire season. Sustaining what RJ did in 200 minutes over an entire season would be an incredible season for the kid. I don’t think it’s fair to expect that PLUS the growth the other 3 players showed their sophomore seasons. It’s very possible, when playing a full season, RJs numbers go down and he is still a very big role on the team. Let’s keep the expectations reined in is all.
 
#266      

Tacomallini

Washington State
It’s also very different to compare 200 minutes to starters minutes for an entire season. Sustaining what RJ did in 200 minutes over an entire season would be an incredible season for the kid. I don’t think it’s fair to expect that PLUS the growth the other 3 players showed their sophomore seasons. It’s very possible, when playing a full season, RJs numbers go down and he is still a very big role on the team. Let’s keep the expectations reined in is all.
Wkwkwkw Reaction GIF by MOODMAN
 
#267      
Found Bernstein's comments. I don't think he was bagging on us unfairly. I think he was being sincere and made some decent points. Here is what he said.

Underwood has done a nice job putting a floor in for the program. Didn't say he stinks or anything. Just needs to adjust his system.

Here were his criticisms.

1. Don't set enough ball screens for guards to get good shots or get to the basket. (fair)

2. System 4 out 1 in is a dated offense and easy to guard. (I think this was a product of personnel and Bernstein doesn’t get that)

3. How can you complain about defensive rebounding when you have 4 guys around the arc. (fair)

4. Sampson went to the NBA to learn offense. High pick n roll leads to open corner 3's. We don't use the corner well.

5. Don't get anything going downhill. We don't have guards that can take their man off the dribble so you need to set more screens.

6. Shouldn't have benched Curbelo, I know he played like garbage but he's a high variance guy and he could play us back into the game. Said, if I'm Curbelo I'm gone. Transferring immediately. How could you trust Underwood after that? Said maybe there is something else there we don’t know about. (TCTORNADO said there was an argument with staff at half so…)

7. Can’t come out of a timeout and make an end bound pass (fair point). You can't turn the ball over when you are the one initiating the action.

8. Underwood's done some great things but has to adjust. You had two all-time greats in program history 2 years in a row and have nothing to show for it.
He’s right Underwood has laid a great foundation…

1.) More Ball Screens…okay. I don’t disagree with certain line ups (Curbelo…and Trent) Ball screens ARE quite efficient and you get a lot of bang for the buck…yet defenses devote a lot of time in preparing for them. My point is there’s a lot ways to skin a cat. Ever see Bellarmine? They have one of the most efficient offenses in the NCAA and they don’t do it with ball screens.

2.) 4 out 1 in…refers to the formation that they initially start out in. It is not an offense, in and of itself…And yes you’re right. I don’t think he gets it at all…We’ve got a an All-American D.Mutumbo-type center with a back to the basket skill set. What does he think Underwood should do? Play 5 out Nelly-Ball completely ignoring our team’s unique personnel situation in favor of doing what’s in vogue…just because? Bad idea.

3.)You mean “offensive” rebounding?
otherwise this does not make sense to me.
We set up on the arc on offense. So we
would be rebounding “offensively” from there. We are where we are on defense relative to the ball and where the offense is…so that’s the starting point from which
we get defensive rebounds…so yeah I dunno? But if he’s saying the spacing is a problem in rebounding…I don’t get that either. There are only so many offensive
formations/sets and they’re all pretty much spaced 15-18 feet apart…even after they
become distorted the spacing is maintained…so it ends up being pretty similar for defensive rebounding. Every team has to deal with that. That comment doesn’t hold up.

4.) High pick and roll leads to corner 3’s…it isn’t that simple.

5.) More movement…I agree…but purposeful movement and not just for
movement’s sake…which is often suggested.

6.) Curbelo? I defer to Brad. We don’t know what happened and neither does Bernstein.

7.) I agree…and I think he will. Give him time..Remember when Self first went to Kansas…didn’t he get bounced in the 1st round a time or two…? At Kansas?? Hard to believe now. (Self took over for a damn solid coach in Lon here )and a hall of famer in Roy there…Underwood certainly wasn’t so lucky. This is just another hurdle.
 
Last edited:
#268      
It’s also very different to compare 200 minutes to starters minutes for an entire season. Sustaining what RJ did in 200 minutes over an entire season would be an incredible season for the kid. I don’t think it’s fair to expect that PLUS the growth the other 3 players showed their sophomore seasons. It’s very possible, when playing a full season, RJs numbers go down and he is still a very big role on the team. Let’s keep the expectations reined in is all.
Agree with this. Taking nothing away from RJ or Goode, but thought it helped both on Sunday that Houston looked completely off-guard when they came in during the first half. Understandably so, can't imagine there's many times in tournament history that that you would go to halftime and two of the top three scorers on a team would have not even played in the game before. Like Houston had done a great job scouting our rotation and knowing what to take away and what to give, but they had no idea what to do with these two. That obviously won't be the case next year, though I expect both to work their tails off and be ready for the bigger roles and expectations.
 
#269      

BBIQ

Texas
He’s right Underwood has laid a great foundation…

1.) More Ball Screens…okay. I don’t disagree with certain line ups (Curbelo…and Trent) Ball screens ARE quite efficient and you get a lot of bang for the buck…yet defenses devote a lot of time in preparing for them. My point is there’s a lot ways to skin a cat. Ever see Bellarmine? They have one of the most efficient offenses in the NCAA and they do it with ball screens.

2.) 4 out 1 in…refers to the formation that initially start out in. It is not an offense, in and of itself…And yes you’re right. I don’t think he gets it at all…We’ve got a an All-American D.Mutumbo-type center with a back to the basket skill set. What does he think Underwood should do? Play 5 out Nelly-Ball completely ignoring our team’s unique personnel situation in favor of doing what’s in vogue…just because? Bad idea.

3.)You mean “offensive” rebounding?
otherwise this does not make sense to me.
We set up on the arc on offense. So we
would be rebounding “offensively” from there. We are where we are on defense relative to the ball and where the offense is…so that’s the starting point from which
we get defensive rebounds…so yeah I dunno? But if he’s saying the spacing is a problem in rebounding…I don’t get that either. There are only so many offensive
formations/sets and they’re all pretty much spaced 15-18 feet apart…even after they
become distorted the spacing is maintained…so it ends up being pretty similar for defensive rebounding. Every team has to deal with that. That comment doesn’t hold up.

4.) High pick and roll leads to corner 3’s…it isn’t that simple.

5.) More movement…I agree…but purposeful movement and not just for
movement’s sake…which is often suggested.

6.) Curbelo? I defer to Brad. We don’t know what happened and neither does Bernstein.

7.) I agree…and I think he will. Give him time..Remember when Self first went to Kansas…didn’t he get bounced in the 1st round a time or two…? At Kansas?? Hard to believe now. (Self took over for a damn solid coach in Lon here )and a hall of famer in Roy there…Underwood certainly wasn’t so lucky. This is just another hurdle.
He said defensive. I think he meant being beaten in the offensive rebound department but saying it in reverse. Which is to say complaining about not getting enough offensive rebounds which is the same as saying Houston getting too many defensive rebounds. that or he misspoke.

In terms of number 4, I was just making quick notes. To expand on that, his point was that it draws defense to the middle of the court which opens up the corners.
 
#270      
He said defensive. I think he meant being beaten in the offensive rebound department but saying it in reverse. Which is to say complaining about not getting enough offensive rebounds which is the same as saying Houston getting too many defensive rebounds. that or he misspoke.

In terms of number 4, I was just making quick notes. To expand on that, his point was that it draws defense to the middle of the court which opens up the corners.
Gotchya
 
#271      
"8. Underwood's done some great things but has to adjust. You had two all-time greats in program history 2 years in a row and have nothing to show for it."

NCAA basketball is about a lot more than just a single elimination tournament.

Conference Championships matter. Conference Tournament championships matter. Developing kids into accountable young men matters. Helping those young men achieve their ambitions matters. Developing a culture that contributes to all those things matters.

BU has a LOT to show for the last two years.
 
#272      
Working 3rd shift, I dvr'ed the game. Deleted it after seeing the score. Finally saw the technical foul. The ref who called that should never call a game again, EVER. Probably would have lost anyway, but damn, that was one of the worst calls ever, ever, ever...
And then to tell Underwood that he shouldn't have made that call, AFTER the fact when it was too late, when he/the ref had already changed the momentum of the game and already deflated Melendez playing - just infuriating! Agree with you 100%!
In fact, it's one of the things that should be happening, if it isn't already: coaches and the NCAA should be recruiting and TRAINING a whole new group of referees, qualified/trained/psychologically sound!! It should be a full-time job, not a side-gig, and there should be regular training and testing updates. The refs can make or break a game and we have seen some pretty horrendous calls and behavior, especially in the Big10 and especially against the Illini.
 
#273      
I thought his comments were mostly reasonable. The only one I strongly disagree with is “nothing to show for it”. But I dont remember him saying that and hadn’t seen it til just now.

I def would have liked to be playing another game or four, but we have a B1G championship and a BTT championship to show for it. Those are “big deals”.

Let’s keep building this thing!! Go Illini!!!
 
#274      

BBIQ

Texas
The only thing BU did that upset me was when Kofi caught that ball in the corner, got trapped and he didn't call timeout. He had all 4 timeouts at the time and it was obvious that was gonna be a turnover. I like BU a lot. I hope everyone understands those were Bernstein's comments not mine.
 
Last edited:
#275      
If I were the father of an Illini player I'd avoid posting. Lots of support, positivity, and gratitude amidst, unfortunately, a great deal of steaming hot takes and bile.

I really liked what Podz brought when he was on the floor and project that he'll get lots more exposure next season.
Agree with you, but also think it's great when Ayo's mother posts (still, on occasion) her support for the Illini and always liked it when Podz' dad posted comments here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.