If you want a guaranteed spot, you do need to sign one. We aren't talking 5 star caliber recruits with UI at the moment that you reserve a spot for. If Tilmon chooses not to sign one and a fifth year 5 wants to commit and is willing to sign, I say take the transfer. Tilmon is not a 5 star anymore, for reason. We've signed too many good players who've declined in similar fashion their last year or two in HS that I want the player who is most likely to contribute in year 1. On top of that if you give any credence to Miggy's post earlier today, I wonder if Tilmon was part of that group where desire, attitude, and motor are in question. Some of us are wayyyy to hung up on the fact that Tilmon was 5 star, very briefly, on some recruiting sites, though not all.