That's really a fictional scenario (5 x 5* centers), so it is really meaningless to compare, other than to artificially feel good about our class.
I like our class' positional balance, but if you ask me whether I would trade it for a realistic class of 5 x 5* players without even knowing their position, I would do it in a heartbeat. You will never get 5 x 5* players in the same position for the simple reason that they will never commit to the same team, so chances are that you will likely hit multiple positions.
Top talent gives you more flexibility and can mask positional gaps (see flyin Illini). Problem is when you get average B1G talent and have positional gaps on top of it, which has been our problem the last few years.