Michigan 13, Western Michigan 12

Status
Not open for further replies.
#227      
If there had any doubt that rigging goes on in College Sports (and by this time there shouldn’t have been) then this horrendous theft of a courageous Western Michigan victory will end all that doubt forever.

Let them come out with their lame excuses and pathetic false justifications. Any fair and honest looking pairs of eyes could see what went on there.

The World knows who really won that game. Western Michigan went into hostile territory and soundly beat the heavily-favored home team all night long – including any phantom last second that only exists in the minds of those concerned with protecting a pathetic and needy-looking program of privilege that apparently could not win the game on the field and needed help from higher-ups concerned about future ratings and Conference National standing and ego.

In being handed this 'win' on a rigged-platter... Michigan became the biggest losers in the Land. If they had any pride (which they don’t) they would simply surrender this win back to Western Michigan who earned it and where it rightfully belongs. But The Maize has no such pride. All they have are sheepish grins from knowing They just stole a game right in front of the entire Nation. And nobody is going to do anything about it.

The Loser became the Winner. The Winner became the Loser.

And a needy and privileged College program just lost even more of its pride and self-respect. Take the Win and the shame that goes with it.

And maybe it's time for the Illini to start to go shopping for a Conference that might still have a shred of integrity left in it. The Illini don't need stench like this.
It wasn't even Illinois that lost

Vine Ok GIF
 
#232      

So I’m honestly trying to understand this.

1) during the broadcast of the last play, they didn’t show the clock in the bottom ribbon like usual. It specifically looked like a direct view of the stadium clock. Was that not the case? Because on that feed it obviously looked like zeros. If it wasn’t a direct feed, do we have any shots of both the stadium clock and the play itself in the same view? Or at least truly and verifiably synced? Looking at the replay posted by rittenberg, it looks like the replay officials are legitimately making the right call.

2. Related to this, is this why it often seems like teams get away with about an extra second on the play clock and delay of games aren’t sometimes called when it looks like they should be? I always thought it was refs inability to look at both the game and the clock at the same time so it causes a bit of an unavoidable delay. But maybe the clock on the broadcast is indeed a bit off?

I’m just trying to legitimately understand this instead of just dusting off my pitchfork without doing some homework
 
#235      
So I’m honestly trying to understand this.

1) during the broadcast of the last play, they didn’t show the clock in the bottom ribbon like usual. It specifically looked like a direct view of the stadium clock. Was that not the case? Because on that feed it obviously looked like zeros. If it wasn’t a direct feed, do we have any shots of both the stadium clock and the play itself in the same view? Or at least truly and verifiably synced? Looking at the replay posted by rittenberg, it looks like the replay officials are legitimately making the right call.

2. Related to this, is this why it often seems like teams get away with about an extra second on the play clock and delay of games aren’t sometimes called when it looks like they should be? I always thought it was refs inability to look at both the game and the clock at the same time so it causes a bit of an unavoidable delay. But maybe the clock on the broadcast is indeed a bit off?

I’m just trying to legitimately understand this instead of just dusting off my pitchfork without doing some homework
Regarding #2: this has always been a case of the ref responsible for looking at the play clock then looks to see if the ball has been snapped. This does buy the offense maybe half a second more. Happens in the stadium, too. It's not a TV/Stadium clock sync issue. Been known and accepted as reality for ever.
 
#236      
The video link in that is awesome! Thanks for sharing.

I didn’t turn on the game until after the !!!! show. Is it true the refs deliberately put 9 seconds on the clock the play before? If so that means, that the clock should be 9.0 seconds.

You’ll see the NBC clock instantly go from 0:09 to 0:08 when the ball is snapped. This leads me to believe the NBC clock is truncating the decimal, and when it shows 0:00 it’s actually 0:00.9

If the refs didn’t deliberately set the clock to 9.0 the play before then the only other way we’d have that instant transition from 0:09 to 0:08 when the ball is snapped is if the tv clock rounded per standard rounding rules, with the clock starting at 0:08.5 but shown as 0:09 on TV. This scenario would technically mean 0.4 seconds remained when the TV clock read 0:00.

I hate to say it but I think technically BIG got this right. To corroborate running my phone stopwatch against the video and game clock seems to agree the play was less than 9 seconds but obviously that method has a lot of uncertainty.

This is an example of when sport clocks are accumulating they should always round down, and when counting down should always round up.

Edit: if you’re watching the video @dsg linked then the PGM view is good for TV clock, and ISO Cam 4 good for timing the play with a stopwatch or general viewing.

Edit 2: I’m curious how NBC shows the 1st second tick off at the start of the quarter but can’t find a video online.
Agree. Probably the right call. However, there are dozens of calls throughout that game that don't get reviewed. It would be interesting to hear the full audio from the time the play ended. No one watching or in the stadium thought there was any question that that game was anything but over. Yet, they chose to review it; pretty quickly.
 
#237      
I take solace this morning that OSU and Oregon are capable of hanging 70 on that Michigan team last night without breaking a sweat. May it be so and may they finish 4-8.

Heartbreaking for those Bronco players and their fans.
 
#239      
Regarding #2: this has always been a case of the ref responsible for looking at the play clock then looks to see if the ball has been snapped. This does buy the offense maybe half a second more. Happens in the stadium, too. It's not a TV/Stadium clock sync issue. Been known and accepted as reality for ever.
Ok noted. Thank you.

Then going back to the first question then, is the clock shown in that play (which wasn’t the ribbon graphic clock) truly the stadium clock or nbc trying to sync and potentially not doing so correctly? Texas a&m forums have an interesting discussion going on about this as well

 
#240      
I think the Refs got it right. If everyone agrees that there was 9 seconds on the playclock, then even just using your own stopwatch at game speed from snap of the ball to the end of the play took less than 9 seconds so there would be time left on the clock.

Maybe football clock should go to decimals. There’s be less confusion although this particular play was very rare
 
#241      
If I was a voter in the polls I drop scUM from the rankings. I would count that as a loss for the rest of the season.
They will certainly drop. If not, the rankings never had much integrity anyway.
 
#245      
They still have to play Oklahoma, Iowa, PSU, IU, Oregon and O$U, so, God willing, all that play will probably mean in the end is they might make the Pinstripe Bowl.
 
#246      
Probably just added another zero to the check and the MAC said "cool".
I know you're being facetious, but where is that 0 going? $1.5 million is what they got. $1.50 million is the same amount, and adding another zero to $1,500,000 is adding $13.5 million.

Sorry, my math brain couldn't.
 
#247      
I think the Refs got it right. If everyone agrees that there was 9 seconds on the playclock, then even just using your own stopwatch at game speed from snap of the ball to the end of the play took less than 9 seconds so there would be time left on the clock.

Maybe football clock should go to decimals. There’s be less confusion although this particular play was very rare
That’s exactly the conversation going on at the Texas a&m forums. I haven’t done it myself but people are saying that if you agree that there are 9seconds and you time the play yourself, the play itself doesn’t take 9 full seconds. And apparently ncaa rules stipulate that even if there’s 0.1seconds in the clock, that round to 1 second
 
#248      
If this is their “evidence”….wow. They used a camera angle where the defenders body blocks the view of the ball. This is just more damning evidence that it was an awful call.
Awful call driven by bias toward bigger, storied schools.

If this had been the opposite - WMU throwing a hail Mary - the game would have been over.

If this was Illinois throwing a hail Mary, the game would have been over.

If this had been Ohio State, the game would have continued and the Buckeyes would have been given another shot.

That's really what happened here. On a bang bang call, the "better" school was given another shot and it flipped the result of the game.
 
#249      
1) during the broadcast of the last play, they didn’t show the clock in the bottom ribbon like usual. It specifically looked like a direct view of the stadium clock. Was that not the case? Because on that feed it obviously looked like zeros. If it wasn’t a direct feed, do we have any shots of both the stadium clock and the play itself in the same view? Or at least truly and verifiably synced? Looking at the replay posted by rittenberg, it looks like the replay officials are legitimately making the right call.
The Big Ten statement claimed the stadium clock (which the broadcast clock is just an altered graphic of) and the clock the replay booth uses are synced before the game.

That seems to have failed.

Begging the question, why does the replay booth clock have authority over the game clock? Surely it doesn't.

But above all else, nobody asked for this lawyered-within-an-inch-of-its-life rulemaxxing around the 3,600th of 3,600 seconds in a football game that isn't present in the other 3,599. Football does not want or need this.

It was a disgraceful farce last night. The Fifth Down Game was an embarrassment to college football, in a stupid lo-fi way that is in some sense true to the sport. There's something much more wicked and inhuman about this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back