Ok but I mean this is a little overstated. There are some red flags with Tilmon perhaps but the tools are there. If he was really so crappy that he'll be this much of a failure everywhere else, how do you expect him to be "the man" here?
First I didn't call him crappy? By being the man, sorry the inside MAN, yes there are several others Smith/Frazier possible/etc as we go on.
As far as his talent...he is not as talented as many others if not most others that UNC/Kansas will or do recruit yearly...this would mean he will get lost in the shuffle, lack of PT against superior talent, possible sulk, get an attitude and or simply transfer out if he goes to any one of those places.
His talent skill set is perfect for ILLINI recruiting him, yes he has skills, skills enough to rank where he is and get recruited by us heavily...you don't see the Blue Bloods chasing him, however, the ILLINI chased him for what 2-3 years...he simply has talent to justify our current state of being able to recruit and be a stud here...not at a Blue Blood.