TSJ Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
#327      
I'm on it as well. I have zero social media and zero connections to the team or university. For me to be able to break any news, it will have to come from my wife. Luckily, she knows everything and is right about everything all the time. I've learned this after 24 years of marriage
She will get even smarter over the next 17 years. I also speak from experience. Can't project beyond that.
 
#328      
I'm curious what the timing is for the defense to get access to the prosecution's evidence.

Shannon has his own texts and emails. Those perhaps exonerate him.

Also, if the bar has a video they can turn it over to the defense.

The police may have turned things over that aren't covered under FOIA but available to defense.

Just a few thoughts of things out there that may be in private hands but not in public realm.
For information helpful to the defense case, Kansas just requires that the disclosure be “timely.” :

The prosecutor must “make timely disclosure to the defense of all evidence or information known to the prosecutor that tends to negate the guilt of the accused or mitigates the offense, and, in connection with sentencing, disclose to the defense and to the tribunal all unprivileged mitigating information known to the prosecutor”

For all other discovery (i.e. witness statements, video footage, etc), it must be disclosed to defendant “upon request”. Federal law requires that it be produced in time for its effective use at trial.

All that to say - we don’t really know but it has to be turned over.
 
Last edited:
#329      
More worried about the other fanbases coming for his throat. Even if he’s completely innocent they’ll never let him live it down.
I'm not worried about opposing teams' fans. If anything, I could see their reactions bringing the team together even more, galvanizing them around their veteran leader who they firmly believe has been unjustly labeled.
 
#330      
More worried about the other fanbases coming for his throat. Even if he’s completely innocent they’ll never let him live it down.
The life of being the star on a nationally ranked team...

These guys(on every team) hear more nasty trash on a night in and night out basis than should be tolerated. They tune it out. The good ones embrace it.
 
#332      

purcy51

Nappanee, IN
I'm on it as well. I have zero social media and zero connections to the team or university. For me to be able to break any news, it will have to come from my wife. Luckily, she knows everything and is right about everything all the time. I've learned this after 24 years of marriage
It took 24 years?!?! I figured it out on day one! 🤷‍♂️
 
#334      
Opposing fans still make Ray Lewis comments. I'm not sure beating a team will silence that team's fans on issues like this that have nothing to do with on court performance.
Do you think Ray Lewis cares?

Do you really think that these high level athletes care? They've been hearing trash since they've been in high school. Have you ever been to a road game and listened to that schools student section? It's brutal. Ask Luther Head how our game at MSU went.

Point being....they tune it out and move on. Fans are going to do fan things.
 
#336      
More worried about the other fanbases coming for his throat. Even if he’s completely innocent they’ll never let him live it down.

Alabama (last year) already gave Illinois the blueprint of what to expect if TS hits the court again this year. If he is innocent, he should be playing period, no matter what some yell, or think.
 
#337      
For information helpful to the defense case, Kansas just requires that the disclosure be “timely.” :

The prosecutor must “make timely disclosure to the defense of all evidence or information known to the prosecutor that tends to negate the guilt of the accused or mitigates the offense, and, in connection with sentencing, disclose to the defense and to the tribunal all unprivileged mitigating information known to the prosecutor”

For all other discovery (i.e. witness statements, video footage, etc), it must be disclosed to defendant “upon request”. Federal law requires that it be produced in time for its effective use at trial.

All that to say - we don’t really know but it has to be turned over.
Thanks. We can presume that Shannon's attorneys have requested it all. If they have it, then they can make their case to the three person board. I wouldn't be surprised to hear the DA is playing games with trying to delay giving it, but that might create both PR and judicial problems.
 
#338      
I guess I just don't understand how they can reinstate him without some kind of public information about the situation becoming available that makes it clear they aren't sweeping it under the rug. Bringing him back with no other facts risks a major backlash nationally.
yeah they wouldn't reinstate without a dropped charge / case thrown away or some sort of plea deal that remove a direct sexual crime from the picture
 
#339      
For information helpful to the defense case, Kansas just requires that the disclosure be “timely.” :

The prosecutor must “make timely disclosure to the defense of all evidence or information known to the prosecutor that tends to negate the guilt of the accused or mitigates the offense, and, in connection with sentencing, disclose to the defense and to the tribunal all unprivileged mitigating information known to the prosecutor”

For all other discovery (i.e. witness statements, video footage, etc), it must be disclosed to defendant “upon request”. Federal law requires that it be produced in time for its effective use at trial.

All that to say - we don’t really know but it has to be turned over.
04-05: Thank you for this important information! The Kansas definition of "timely" disclosure is so frustrating to all of us in ILLINI Nation because moving under the presumption that TSJ is innocent (as the law requires!) then "timely" disclosure of some actual facts might (wishful thinking?) result in the dismissal of these charges and a quicker reinstatement of TSJ to his incredible team and a return to the court where he really belongs. But in the bigger picture, what is far more important than TSJ's quick reinstatement to the orange and blue is that at this moment he is facing a felony charge of rape and, if convicted, he could face a minimum mandatory sentence of 12 years to a maximum sentence of 54 years in prison and/or a fine of up to $300,000 along with 3 years of post release supervision. Think of how terrifying that must be, especially if you know you are innocent of the charges brought against you by this District Attorney. Let's all slow down the discussion about his return to the basketball court until this far more serious situation is resolved. Basketball is a distant second in importance right now for this young ILLINI who has represented the University in such admirable fashion in the past and whose life will be severely impacted no matter what happens now.
 
#340      
Alabama (last year) already gave Illinois the blueprint of what to expect if TS hits the court again this year. If he is innocent, he should be playing period, no matter what some yell, or think.
Miller was never charged though. TJ was and that's why any reinstatement must be done in consideration of those charges and in my opinion likely needing the charges dropped. JW reiterated a zero tolerance policy... Which is the right move but that means no plea bargain or deals since that usually is seen as a form of guilt in the court of public opinion. May be totally allowed but optics do matter. And this is assuming he is completely innocent
 
#341      
I would be willing to bet my beach house that the majority of the demographic that funds Illinois athletics would be very upset with Josh if it came out that an inevitable TSJ reinstatement was delayed just to appear more woke or PC.
This is not about “woke” or PC. It is about policy, procedure, and yes, PR. Leadership cannot come across as subverting a court proceeding for basketball success. The University must be smart, nimble and principled in all aspects here.
 
#342      
Miller was never charged though. TJ was and that's why any reinstatement must be done in consideration of those charges and in my opinion likely needing the charges dropped. JW reiterated a zero tolerance policy... Which is the right move but that means no plea bargain or deals since that usually is seen as a form of guilt in the court of public opinion. May be totally allowed but optics do matter. And this is assuming he is completely innocent
No, assuming he's completely innocent and the allowance is made...optics do not matter.

In today's day and age of college athletics with regards to recruiting, NIL and the portal... we're talking about optics?

C'mon.

Edit:

Again, we're assuming that he's completely innocent and that being the case....what are the optics of TSJ right now? I'm confused as to why you're not thinking about that young man? Your focus is on a CYA from the school and not doing what's right by the kid.
 
Last edited:
#343      
More worried about the other fanbases coming for his throat. Even if he’s completely innocent they’ll never let him live it down.

Don't worry ... Brad has reached out to a special officer to make sure TJ doesn't deal with any fans who may take it too far ...

Screenshot 2024-01-03 at 8.40.44 PM.png
 
#344      
To everyone out there that is saying they need to reinstate TSJ only if the charges are dropped or if there is a plea deal that will eliminate the direct sexual crime, what makes you think that will not happen? What evidence that we have heard or seen gives you that impression?
 
Last edited:
#346      
To everyone out there that thinks they need to reinstate TSJ only if the charges are dropped or if there is a plea deal that will eliminate the direct sexual crime, what makes you think that that will not happen? What evidence that we have heard or seen gives you that impression?
It's not that there's been evidence that points to that, its actually the exact opposite - there has not been any evidence (legal evidence) to indicate the case will not proceed. If the case proceeds as scheduled, the legal process will not play out in time.

The status quo scenario here is he is out for quite some time that extends beyond the season. If something changes that allows for a return, that is awesome but not the status quo scenario
 
#347      
Miller was never charged though. TJ was and that's why any reinstatement must be done in consideration of those charges and in my opinion likely needing the charges dropped. JW reiterated a zero tolerance policy... Which is the right move but that means no plea bargain or deals since that usually is seen as a form of guilt in the court of public opinion. May be totally allowed but optics do matter. And this is assuming he is completely innocent
As I said, if TJ is innocent, I don't care about the optics.

Miller (alabama) was never charged because there was no crime to charge him with. Alabama's star player brought the gun to the scene where it was used to commit homicide. That is not debatable, yet bama survived those optics and Miller was even defended by most broadcasters doing their games nationally.
 
#348      
To everyone out there that is saying they need to reinstate TSJ only if the charges are dropped or if there is a plea deal that will eliminate the direct sexual crime, what makes you think that will not happen? What evidence that we have heard or seen gives you that impression?
Are there any examples in the past 5 years (since the me too movement) when a college athlete charged with rape played in college again? Sure someone will find one but literally cannot think of one example in college (only examples I can think are lesser charges like domestic assault or sexual assault that were dropped but none with rape).
 
#349      
Are there any examples in the past 5 years (since the me too movement) when a college athlete charged with rape played in college again? Sure someone will find one but literally cannot think of one example in college (only examples I can think are lesser charges like domestic assault or sexual assault that were dropped but none with rape).
So you think he committed the crime then?
 
#350      

IlliniKat91

Chicago, IL
To everyone out there that is saying they need to reinstate TSJ only if the charges are dropped or if there is a plea deal that will eliminate the direct sexual crime, what makes you think that will not happen? What evidence that we have heard or seen gives you that impression?
For me it's not about not having evidence, but I worry we wouldn't survive the optics of it. We do need to keep recruiting after TSJ leaves, after all, and you don't want coaches from opposing teams smearing us our or practices when we're in tight recruiting battles. We'd weather it because we have a staff that's great at identifying talent, but I don't think the DIA would want to do something that would make it any more difficult for them if possible to avoid it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.